DIY screen material vs Carl's Place - is the premium worth $400?

I can get impact screen material from various sources for about $150-200 for a 10x10 panel. Carl's Place wants $500+ for a similar size.

Is there really that much difference? I've seen people on YouTube using shower curtain liners and painters tarps lol. Obviously I want something better than that, but do I need to spend $500?

What I care about:

• Durability (I hit about 200-300 balls per week)
• Image quality for projection
• Ball return (nice to have but not essential)
• Low noise on impact

Anyone tried both cheap and premium options?